If you are comparing dubia roaches vs crickets for bearded dragon dinners, you are really deciding between Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches and Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets. Both are raised as live feeders for insect eating pets, and both list bearded dragons as a target species. Your decision affects smell in your reptile room, how often you clean, and how hard your dragon has to hunt for each bite.
You want the feeder that matches your dragon’s age, your tolerance for chirping and escapes, and how many mouths you feed each week. As of November 2026, I still see keepers split on this, with some loving the calm dubia tub and others swearing their slow eaters only chase crickets. For broader feeding context, browse the Feeder Insects: Crickets, Dubia and BSFL hub before you stock up.
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through one of our links, DragonPop may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions never influence which products we recommend or how we rank them. Read our Affiliate Disclosure for details.
Quick Picks at a Glance
Prime Josh's Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches 250 Count
Prime Josh's Frogs 3/4 Inch Banded Feeder Crickets 500
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.
Pros
- More nutritious and digestible than crickets thanks to high protein and soft shell
- No noise, no odor and minimal escape risk for hassle free keeping
- Perfectly sized for popular medium insectivores including bearded dragons and geckos
- Bulk size choices and generous weighing provide great value for multi pet homes
Cons
- Count and size may vary slightly since packs are sorted by size and weighed
- Live insects require proper warmth, food and housing promptly on arrival
- Not legal to ship to every US state, so buyers must check local restrictions
Josh's Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches in the 250 count pack are live feeder insects sized from 1/2 to 3/4 inch for medium insectivores. They are made for bearded dragons, leopard geckos, fat tailed geckos, chameleons, frogs, toads and spiders.
The standout benefit is nutrition with high protein and a soft, low chitin shell that is easier to digest than crickets. In daily feeding, they offer active movement that triggers feeding response while staying quiet and calm in the enclosure.
Keeping and handling is simple since Dubia roaches cannot fly or climb smooth surfaces, so escapes are rare. Josh's Frogs sorts by size and packs by weight in your favor, with live arrival packaging and a care sheet included for proper setup.
There are a few tradeoffs to know. Counts and sizes can vary slightly because packs are weighed, and live insects need prompt care with warmth, food and ventilation on arrival. They are also not legal to ship to every US state, so check your location first.
Overall, this 250 count medium pack is a smart choice for multi reptile homes or frequent feeders that want clean, nutritious and low maintenance prey. If you want a better cricket alternative that supports healthy growth, these Dubia roaches deliver excellent value and convenience.
Feed medium Dubia roaches that are no larger than the space between your reptile's eyes for safe swallowing. Offer 3 to 5 appropriately sized roaches per feeding for most medium insectivores, adjusting for age and appetite.
Store roaches in a smooth sided bin with egg crates, warmth and dry gut load plus fresh vegetables for hydration. Remove uneaten prey after a few hours and keep the bin clean and ventilated to prevent odor.
Pros
- Healthy, active crickets arrive ready to feed and gut load
- Long survival for weeks with basic food, hydration and ventilation
- Softer shell supports easier digestion for reptiles and amphibians
- Bulk 500 count is economical for multiple pets or frequent feeding
- Versatile for all life stages and many reptile, amphibian and bird species
Cons
- 500 count requires a large ventilated habitat and regular cleaning
- Transferring crickets from shipping carton to keeper can be messy with escapes
- Live insects need prompt setup on arrival or some early loss can occur
Josh's Frogs 3/4 inch banded crickets are bulk live feeders sold in a 500 count carton for reptiles, amphibians and other insectivores. They are sized for subadult and adult leopard geckos, bearded dragons, chameleons, tree frogs, Pac-Man frogs and sugar gliders.
Banded crickets stand out for hardiness, high protein nutrition and a softer exoskeleton that supports digestion. Their constant movement triggers strong feeding responses, which helps with picky eaters, and keepers report they survive for weeks with proper food, hydration and ventilation.
Packaging is built for live transit with a secure carton and protective egg crate plus food and hydration support. The Gryllodes sigillatus species is quieter and lower odor than many common feeders, which makes bulk indoor keeping more manageable.
Bulk volume is the main tradeoff, since 500 crickets need a roomy ventilated keeper and regular cleaning. Transfer from the shipping box can be tricky and a few escapes or early losses are possible if setup is delayed or overcrowded.
For reptile and frog keepers who feed often or house multiple pets, this is a practical, nutritious and economical feeder option. With basic gut loading and routine care, it delivers active prey, strong survival and consistent feeding results.
Banded crickets thrive in a well ventilated container with egg crate for climbing space and reduced crowding. Provide a dry gut load diet plus a safe hydration source, and keep the enclosure warm, dry and clean.
Gut load 24 to 48 hours before feeding and dust with reptile vitamins and calcium as directed for your species. Offer appropriately sized crickets that match the space between your pet's eyes for safe feeding.
Remove waste and uneaten food regularly and avoid excess moisture to control odor and extend survival. Plan keeper size in advance when ordering bulk quantities to prevent overcrowding.
How They Compare
Size and Life Stage Fit
Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches are sorted from 1/2 inch to 3/4 inch, while Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets are sold at 3/4 inch. That puts both in a useful middle range for dragons past the tiny hatchling stage, not pinhead size and not large adult size. Keepers commonly report choosing feeder length based on the space between the eyes, so you can see why these two sizes get compared so often.
In practice, I reach for Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches when I want a meatier, slower moving bite for juveniles learning to chew and for adults that prefer less chase. I reach for Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets when I want constant motion to wake up a sleepy or picky dragon. If your dragon is very small or older with weak aim, neither middle size is perfect without close supervision at feeding time.
Nutrition, Hydration and Digestibility
Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches are described as high in protein with a low chitin shell, which is why many keepers call them easy to digest and good for steady growth. Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets are also described as a rich protein source with natural hydration levels and highly digestible nutrition. Both need proper gut loading and dusting habits to round out calcium and vitamins, neither is complete on its own.
The difference is texture and water content more than protein alone. Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches offer a softer bodied roach with less shell crunch, so you might notice firmer stools and less leftover exoskeleton in the dish. Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets are marketed with a softer shell and exoskeleton for a cricket, plus active prey enrichment that encourages natural hunting. For help building a rotation, see the feeder insects care section and pair either option with greens and proper supplementation.
Noise, Odor and Escape Control
This is where Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches pull ahead for apartment keepers. They cannot climb smooth surfaces or fly, so escapes are rare, and they produce no noise and no odor when kept properly. Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets are banded crickets, which are noted as lower odor and quieter than many feeder bugs, but they are still lively jumpers that can slip through a loose lid.
For daily care, Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches sit calmly in a smooth sided tub with egg flats, chow and water crystals, and you can pick out what you need with tongs. Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets arrive packed with protective egg crate support and need a ventilated container with food and hydration to hold them for weeks. If chirping at night or smell in a small room bothers you, you will notice the difference within the first few days.
Pack Sizes and Weekly Feeding Rhythm
Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches are available in six bulk sizes, including 25, 50, 100, 250, 500, or 1000 count, and they are sorted by size then packaged by weight so count might vary slightly. Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets in this listing is a 500 count box, which suits a single hungry juvenile for a short burst or a small collection. If you only feed one adult a few times per week, the smaller dubia packs create less waste and less crowding.
Keepers commonly report that dubia survive longer in the tub with less die off, while banded crickets are described as hardy with long storage and excellent colony survival for bulk stock management. In my routine, Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches are easier to stretch across many feedings, while Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets work best when you plan active feedings several days in a row. Check the Feeder Insects: Crickets, Dubia and BSFL archive to match pack size to your feeding schedule.
Which One Should You Get
Choose Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches if you keep a juvenile or young adult that eats daily and you want a slow moving, easy to digest staple. You will appreciate the 1/2 inch to 3/4 inch sizing for tong or dish feeding, and the ability to start with 25, 50, or 100 before committing to 250 or more. This fits keepers who want quiet tubs with rare escapes and no chirping in a bedroom, office, or shared living space.
Choose Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets if your bearded dragon is an active hunter that ignores still feeders and needs movement to trigger strikes. You will like the 3/4 inch active prey for enrichment, plus the 500 count format if you feed multiple dragons or a juvenile that eats often. This fits keepers who can manage a ventilated cricket bin with egg crate as shown in the feeder insects hub and who do not mind a livelier, more hands on routine.
My Experience
I have used both in my front opening enclosure over the past few seasons, but I keep coming back to Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches for my adult female because she is a slow, deliberate eater. I set a smooth sided dish, add a few 1/2 inch to 3/4 inch roaches, and they stay put instead of scattering behind decor. I still order Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets when I want to enrich her week, the 3/4 inch jumpers get her running, but I only do that when I have time to clean the bin and catch strays.
Who Should Skip Both
These two live staples are not ideal for keepers who cannot keep any live insects at home, such as dorm residents with strict no bug rules or families with severe roach or cricket sensitivities. They are also not the right choice if your dragon is on a vet prescribed soft diet after mouth injury or illness and cannot chase or chew whole prey right now. In those cases, talk to your reptile vet about temporary alternatives and revisit live feeders from the feeder insects hub once your setup allows.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are dubia roaches better than crickets for bearded dragons?
Many keepers prefer Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches for daily feeding because they are quiet, rarely escape, and have a low chitin shell. Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets can be better for picky hunters that need movement, so the best choice depends on your dragon’s appetite and your housing situation.
Can I feed Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches and banded crickets in the same week?
Yes, many keepers rotate both to add variety, using dubia as the calm base and 3/4 inch banded crickets for enrichment feeds. Keep each species in its own ventilated tub with egg crate, food, and hydration. Always gut load and dust according to the supplement maker and your vet’s advice.
Which smells less, medium dubia roaches or 3/4 inch banded crickets?
Josh’s Frogs Medium Dubia Roaches produce no odor when kept properly and are usually the cleaner smelling option. Josh’s Frogs 3/4″ Banded Feeder Crickets for Pets are described as lower odor and quieter than many feeder bugs, but a crowded 500 count bin will still need regular cleaning and ventilation to stay fresh.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!